High Conflict Divorce

MicrophoneHave a listen to Stan Prowse - Divorce Isn't Therapy Segment 
Divorce and Mental Illness

High Conflict Divorce Cases and Mental Illness

Divorce lawyers refer to some divorces as "high conflict divorce cases."  Over the past few years we've realized that some form of mental illness drives many of them.

High conflict cases usually involve child custody and visitation.  The parties cannot agree on anything and fight about everything.  The cases  go on interminably through numerous motion hearings and are resolved only by trials. I'm neither a psychologist nor a psychiatrists, so I'll keep my comments on this phenomenon in plain English.

Consideration of mental illness may help answer some puzzling questions in high conflict cases where one or possibly both parents posses a high conflict personality.  For example, why is Mom so convinced after separation that Dad is a terrible parent who should get supervised visitation only, when prior to their separation Dad's parenting skills seemed acceptable?  Why is there such a disconnect between the available evidence and Mom's accusations of Dad's unfitness?  We could easily reverse the genders.

Children And A Parents Self Worth

We now understand that some parents sense of self-worth is excessively and intimately bound up with their children.  They are overly dependent upon them.  If they feel threatened with the loss of a child to the other parent, they feel threatened as well with the loss of their own identity and their reason for being.  They can't let go, and consequently tend to view the child as their exclusive personal property.

This inevitably produces a battle with the other parent over the child's affection and loyalty, which in turn harms the child's own sense of self-worth, reduces the child's ability to trust others, and generally makes the child miserable.  The overly invested parent will probably try, figuratively or literally, to take the child away from the other parent.

Assuming we decide that the overly dependent, overly invested parent is abnormal to the extent of mental illness, what do we do about it?  The courts can do very little to help such a parent.  He or she can only be ordered to outpatient "counseling," and for no more than a year.  The court can also order a psychological evaluation and a custody evaluation, but neither is therapeutic.

High Conflict Child Custody And Visitation Disputes

From a practical standpoint, introducing mental illness into the mix may do little more than provide the court with something else to lean on when it makes child custody and visitation orders in high conflict cases.  Genuine mental illness suggests the potential futility of attempting to settle high conflict child custody and visitation disputes by negotiation.  Unfortunately, it also suggests that aggressive advocacy on behalf of the mentally ill parent before and at trial will be counterproductive for both parents and for the child.

In my practive I remain mindful of these consideratins at all imes in high conflict cases.  When mental illness appears to be a factor in my client's behavior, I do everything possible, with tact and discretion, to induce my cleint to recognize his or her problems and voluntarily enter long tern serious therapy.

San Diego Divorce Attorney Stanley D. Prowse welcomes your legal inquiries.

Five Star Review Review       On Yelp

    "I went to see Mr. Prowse about a pending divorce. He was very informative. Since this was a long term divorce, I was nervous and scared at the same time. After I met with him, I felt relieved and relaxed. HIs staff was very empathic and compassionate. I would highly recommend Mr. Prowse to anyone going through the same situation".

If you find this article helpful, Please leave us a Review here.

Review Us
Law Office of Stanley D. Prowse
7206 Aviara Drive
Carlsbad, CA 92011
Share This Page
Follow Us